Login  |  Contact Us  |  Shopping Cart
 
 
 
 
 
 
 



Two Philosophies of Translation: Sidebar
Article Extras
Main article: It’s All Greek to Me

 E-Mail This       Print This

Issue #132 November/December 2002

Two Philosophies of Translation

Formal Equivalence (-for-)

Strengths

Weaknesses

Greater word-for-word correspondence with the original text

Awkward English at times; less readable

Less interpretation of the original text; less reliance on the translator for an accurate interpretation

More ambiguity in the meaning of the English; relies on the reader for more interpretation

Better for in-depth biblical study

More difficult for a nonChristian or a new Christian to read and comprehend

Easier to trace the same form of a word used by the biblical writers

Not as good for public Scripture reading

More precision by using complex vocabulary and theological terminology

May lead readers to reach wrong interpretive conclusions in a casual reading

Dynamic Equivalence (Thought-for-Thought)

Strengths

Weaknesses

More readable

Less correspondence to the form of the original text

Priority on conveying meaning; thus, less ambiguity in the meaning of the English text

More interpretation of the original text

Easy for a nonChristian or a new Christian to read and comprehend

Not as good for careful Bible study

Good for public Scripture reading

Impossible to trace the same form of a word used by the biblical writers

More interpretation by trained scholars

Often more expansive by using a phrase or sentence to explain a technical term



Copyright ©2007, The Navigators, Discipleship Journal. All rights reserved.


Permission is granted to make up to 100 copies of this Discipleship Journal article for non-commercial use with small groups, Sunday school classes, etc. The following credit must appear on each copy:

"Used by permission of Discipleship Journal™. Copyright © 1981-2006, The Navigators. Used by permission of NavPress. All Rights Reserved. To subscribe, visit www.discipleshipjournal.com or call 1-800-877-1811."